Climate Risk Data Quality: Six Tests to Run Before CSRD and IFRS S2 Assurance

Climate Risk Data Quality: Six Tests to Run Before CSRD and IFRS S2 Assurance

Updated 16 Nov 2026 · Published 09 Oct 2026 · 10 min read

Edward Packshaw (LinkedIn)

Lead Climate Compliance Researcher

Contents

Key takeaways

  • → Climate risk data holds up under assurance when a reviewer can trace each site-level figure to a named dataset, a documented method and a dated version.
  • → Six tests cover most data quality gaps: availability, reliability, comparability, accessibility, granularity and forward-looking scenarios.
  • → An undocumented estimate or an unexplained change of method between years tends to become an assurance finding, and the figure gets rebuilt under deadline.
  • → SmartResilience attaches documented methodology, data lineage and change logs to every site-level climate risk figure.

Many sustainability teams find out their climate data is weak when an assurance provider asks where one site's flood loss figure came from and nobody can rebuild it. The answer usually turns out to be spread across a spreadsheet, a consultant's PDF and a model version nobody can open. Under the EU's Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) and IFRS S2, the International Financial Reporting Standards climate disclosure standard issued by the International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB), that question is becoming routine. This guide sets out six tests your team can run on its physical climate risk data before the next reporting cycle and how to document what the data cannot cover.

Why does climate data face more scrutiny now that TCFD has moved into IFRS S2?

Climate data faces more scrutiny because the standards that replaced the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) recommendations increasingly put those figures in front of an assurance provider or a regulator.

The timeline to know:

Each regime asks the same thing of a disclosed climate figure: show where it came from. Most of them also share a common root, because the voluntary frameworks companies used to report against, TCFD among them, have been consolidated under the IFRS Foundation:

A diagram showing how major sustainability reporting frameworks, including TCFD, SASB, CDP and the Value Reporting Foundation, have been absorbed into or aligned with the IFRS Foundation since 2022. ISSB issued IFRS S1 and S2 in June 2023 as the unified global standard. EFRAG (CSRD) and GRI sit alongside IFRS under formal interoperability agreements. Source: IFC.

That shared root means that much of the climate data prepared for IFRS S2 carries across to UK SRS reporting on physical climate risk, and the ISSB and the European Financial Reporting Advisory Group (EFRAG) have published guidance on how it maps to ESRS. However, requirements still differ by jurisdiction and company size, so organisations should take independent legal and accounting advice on their specific obligations.

What are the six climate data quality requirements and what do they mean in practice?

The six climate data quality requirements are availability, reliability, comparability, accessibility, granularity and forward-looking scenarios.

Each one has a recognisable failure:

data-quality-tests-card

Two of these tests often pull against each other. When a manufacturer replaces its single portfolio score with site-level average annual loss (AAL) and probable maximum loss (PML) figures, granularity improves overnight and comparability with last year's disclosure breaks. That trade is worth making, provided the change and the reason for it go on record alongside the new numbers. AAL and PML are the metrics most teams use to put a financial figure on physical climate risk, so getting them right at site level pays off well beyond the disclosure.

How should your team document estimates and proxies?

Your team documents estimates and proxies best in an estimates register: a single log that names each gap, the substitute used, the reason for choosing it and the date it will be reviewed. IFRS S2 lets companies use reasonable and supportable information that is available without undue cost or effort, so an estimate holds up when the reasoning behind it is on record.

Building the register takes four steps:

  1. Find the gaps: Work through each site and each hazard, and note every place where no direct data exists.

  2. Choose the proxy: Pick the best substitute available without undue cost or effort, such as a regional dataset or the nearest comparable site, and record its version.

  3. Write down why: Record why that proxy beat the alternatives, because the IFRS S2 test turns on the reasoning as much as the number.

  4. Set a review date: Decide when the estimate gets revisited, so a placeholder does not roll forward unexamined into a third reporting cycle.

A log of every estimate and the proxy behind it is one of the first things an assurance provider looks for when they test how a physical risk figure was built. Keeping it up to date through the year saves a scramble when the review begins.

Practical tip: Start the register with the sites that carry the most insured value. A proxy behind a small store matters far less to an assurance provider than one behind a distribution centre holding a fifth of the portfolio's stock.

Regional screening tool. For asset-level precision, Book a free session.

How can you score the data behind each site?

Teams can score the data behind each site on a five-point scale, from site-specific modelled data at the top to sector or portfolio averages at the bottom. The idea borrows from the data quality scores the Partnership for Carbon Accounting Financials (PCAF) uses for financed emissions.

From strongest to weakest:

Score 1: Hazard data is modelled at the building footprint, with verified coordinates and a current asset value.

Score 2: Hazard data is modelled for the site, with coordinates taken from the asset register but not checked against the footprint.

Score 3: Hazard data sits at postcode or grid-cell level and is matched to the site address.

Score 4: The figure relies on a proxy from a comparable nearby site or a regional dataset.

Score 5: The figure uses a sector or portfolio average with no site-specific input, which is common for newly acquired sites.

No standard prescribes this scale for physical risk. Once every site has a score, though, your team can report the share of insured value at each level, which gives the board and the assurance provider one view of where the data is strong and shows where the next round of data collection pays back most.

Who should own each part of the data before sign-off?

Ownership of climate risk data usually splits across four teams, and each part needs a named person accountable for it before sign-off. In many organisations the asset register sits with property, asset values with finance and the climate model with sustainability. When those three files carry different dates, nobody can rebuild a disclosed figure with confidence.

Clear ownership looks like this:

  • Facilities or property: The facilities team owns the asset register, meaning site locations, building types and floor levels, because a wrong coordinate changes every hazard figure attached to that site.

  • Finance: The finance team owns asset and stock values and total insured value (TIV), which turn hazard exposure into the financial figures in the disclosure.

  • Sustainability: The sustainability team owns the choice of hazard datasets, emissions scenarios and time horizons, and records every change between years.

  • Risk or internal audit: A reviewer outside the preparing team signs off the final figures and the estimate register before they reach the assurance provider.

Agreeing one data cut-off date across all four teams is often the quickest fix available. It costs a single meeting and closes the version gap between the three files.

How SmartResilience helps you build climate risk data that stands up to assurance

Most teams that work through these six tests find the same pattern: the data exists, but it sits in different files, versions and teams. SmartResilience Climate Assessments bring it into one documented place:

  • Site-level figures from named sources: The platform models flood, heat, wind, water stress and wildfire for every site, using documented sources including IPCC AR6 (the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change's Sixth Assessment Report), JBA UK flood data and CMIP6 (the sixth phase of the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project) climate projections.

  • Methodology and data lineage behind every number: Your team can export the assumptions, inputs and lineage behind any AAL or PML figure and share them with your assurance provider.

  • Auditable change logs: The platform logs every change to a dataset, scenario or asset record with its date, so your team can explain any movement from one disclosure to the next.

  • Scenarios and horizons set to your plan: The platform runs Representative Concentration Pathway (RCP) 2.6, 4.5 and 8.5 emissions scenarios over any year to 2100 and produces IFRS S2 aligned outputs that support CSRD and UK SRS reporting.

SmartResilience

See SmartResilience in action

Book a free session tailored to your organisation and sites.

Book a free session

SmartResilience works with your sustainability, finance and facilities teams as a long-term partner, reviewing hazard data twice a year and keeping site figures live as the portfolio changes. One customer replaced a consultancy report with this approach, rolled it out across 53 countries in six weeks and cut its climate risk analysis costs by more than 50% compared with its previous provider.

Where should your team start?

Start where the assurance provider will: pick one figure from last year’s disclosure and try to rebuild it from your own files. If that works, run all six tests on the five sites carrying the most insured value and log every gap you find. If it does not, the next reporting cycle needs a change in how the data is produced as well as better documentation, and that is a decision worth taking now rather than in the weeks before sign-off.

FAQs

Is TCFD still valid?

The TCFD disbanded in October 2023 after the ISSB took over monitoring of climate disclosures. Its recommendations continue inside IFRS S2 and UK SRS S2, so a disclosure built on TCFD's four pillars still has a sound structure. New disclosures should be prepared and referenced against IFRS S2.

Does CSRD still apply after the Omnibus changes?

CSRD still applies to EU companies with more than 1,000 employees and over €450m net turnover. The Omnibus package narrowed the scope and kept assurance at the limited level, so companies that remain in scope face the same expectation that each climate figure can be traced to its source.

Can climate disclosures use estimated data?

Climate disclosures can use estimates. IFRS S2 allows reasonable and supportable information available without undue cost or effort, and ESRS permits estimates where direct data is unavailable. Assurance providers look for a documented reason for each estimate, the proxy used and a plan to replace it with better data.

What is the difference between portfolio-level and site-level climate data?

Portfolio-level data gives one aggregate score for a group of assets. Site-level data breaks that down by individual location, so it shows which sites face which hazards and what each could cost. Most disclosure standards expect material risks to be identifiable at a level a reader can act on, which in practice means site level.

What are the dimensions of data quality?

General data quality frameworks usually list accuracy, completeness, consistency, timeliness and validity. For climate disclosure, the six tests in this guide apply those ideas to physical risk data: availability, reliability, comparability, accessibility, granularity and forward-looking scenarios.

Does UK SRS S2 require scenario analysis?

UK SRS S2 follows IFRS S2 in asking companies to assess climate resilience using scenario analysis proportionate to their circumstances. The standard is voluntary for now, and the FCA has proposed requiring listed companies to report against it for periods beginning on or after 1 January 2027.

Related articles

View all resources
5 steps to a physical climate risk assessment for real estate and property portfolios 18 Nov 2026

5 steps to a physical climate risk assessment for real estate and property portfolios

Read more →
How to write a climate risk RFP: a guide to choosing a climate risk platform 17 Nov 2026

How to write a climate risk RFP: a guide to choosing a climate risk platform

Read more →
Heat risk for UK businesses: how multi-site operators can prepare for heatwaves 23 Oct 2026

Heat risk for UK businesses: how multi-site operators can prepare for heatwaves

Read more →